Opponents say death proves Red Light Cameras don’t save lives

By Betsy Dolan 

redlightsA fatal accident on December 8 at an intersection with red light cameras, has reinvigorated the program’s opponents who refute the Sugar Land’s position that the program saves lives.

Sugar Land Police say that footage from the red light cameras at U.S. 90A and Dairy Ashford show that 25-year old Carlos Ybarra of Alamo, died after he ran a red light and hit a woman driving a Chevy Tahoe. A witness at the scene originally told police that the woman ran the red light. Alcohol is not believed to have been a factor in the crash.

The City of Sugar Land has maintained that red light cameras have reduced accidents by 58% and are an important safety tool at high volume intersections. But Helwig Van Der Grinten (Captain Van), who is leading the charge to eliminate the program, says the December 8 fatality is a good example of how red light cameras don’t save lives.

“Typically this type of accident occurs well into the red light period and these violations are caused by an impaired or distracted driver,” Captain Van wrote in an email to the “Star“. “When a traffic light turns yellow drivers must base a snap stop-or-go decision on where they think they might be when the light changes to red”.

City of Sugar Land spokesman, Doug Adolph says that the police department has several traffic safety enforcement programs designed to encourage drivers to follow traffic laws, including red light cameras.

“Red light cameras are one of the programs that the chief (Doug Brinkley) has identified as a method to reduce side impact crashes that lead to fatalities and serious injury”, said Adolph.

On November 19, Van Der Grinten’s group, the Houston Coalition Against Red Light Cameras, suffered a set back when the Traffic Safety Task Force recommended that the red light program remain with a few modifications. The city council is expected to make a decision on the recommendations after the first of the year.

Captain Van continues to push for the red light camera issue to be put on the ballot and voted on by Sugar Land residents. He has started a legal action fund to raise $5,000 to force the City of Sugar Land to put the issue to a vote. Paul Kubosh, an attorney who was successfully in his fight to ban red light cameras in Houston two years ago, has contributed.

Short URL: http://www.fortbendstar.com/?p=36972

Posted by on Dec 23 2013. Filed under Breaking News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

1 Comment for “Opponents say death proves Red Light Cameras don’t save lives”

  1. Red light cameras are about money, not safety. Almost all tickets go to drivers for violations of less than one second into the red. Almost all dangerous T-bone and angle crashes are for violations of at least two and more normally five to nine or more seconds into the red.

    Red light cameras ticket safe drivers who don’t cause crashes.

    They do NOT stop the dangerous drivers that injure and kill people.

    James C. Walker, Life Member-National Motorists Association

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Search Archive

Search by Date
Search by Category
Search with Google
Log in | Copyright © 2011 by Fortbendstar.com | All rights reserved.